Note: Pet Educate is reader supported. If you make a purchase through a link on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission - at no extra cost to you. This includes links to Amazon.

OptimPlus Dog Food Review [Read This Before You Buy!]

If you frequently shop at Pet Supplies Plus, you’ve likely noticed their exclusive in-house brand, OptimPlus. Its affordable pricing may have caught your eye.

But is OptimPlus truly an optimal choice for your dog?

How does it compare to alternatives in meeting yours dog’s nutritional needs?

Well today, I am going to be helping you made a more informed choice as to whether transitioning over is something that you decide to do.

Short on time? Here is my OptimPlus dog food review:

OptimPlus Dog Food Recommended Alternative

Quick Verdict

Based on nutritional analysis and having reviewed n extensive range of customer reviews, I wouldn’t personally recommend OptimPlus.

Instead, I would treat your dog to human-grade meals tailored specifically to their needs.

For that, Sundays for Dogs is the way to go.

They deliver some of the most nutrient-dense human-grade recipes on the market that are 90% meat 10% added superfoods; nothing else.

They can offer you a customized plan to suit your dog – depending on its breed, age, and sensitivities.

Food is effortless to serve and enjoyed even by picky eaters.

Shipped to your door at lower cost than other fresh brands, with less waste.

Who Makes OptimPlus Dog Food?

Pet Supplies Plus makes OptimPlus. It is their private label line and in-house brand of pet food.

In other words, OptimPlus dog food is made and sold exclusively by Pet Supplies Plus; one of the largest pet retail chains in the United States.

They operate both physical locations and have a large online presence through their website:

Founded in Michigan in 1988, Pet Supplies Plus has grown to over 700 stores in 36 states, making it a major presence in the pet specialty market.

What Varieties and Formulations of OptimPlus Are There?

Pet Supplies Plus offers both dry and wet OptimPlus dog food, with the latter introduced in 2023.

Among their dry food selections, two standout products are the “Sensitive Skin & Stomach” formula, designed to support dogs with dietary sensitivities, and the wholesome “Chicken and Brown Rice Formula”, tailored to offer an everyday option.

What I Like About OptimPlus Dog Food

Affordable Price Point

The top advantage of OptimPlus is its budget-friendly pricing.

Formulas cost significantly less than premium or veterinarian-recommended brands.

This makes OptimPlus attractive if you are on a tight budget or if you have multiple dogs to feed.

Ease of Ordering

With Pet Supplies Plus locations across 36 states plus online ordering, OptimPlus offers broad accessibility and convenience:

  • Can purchase in-store at over 700 Pet Supplies Plus retail locations
  • Available online for delivery direct to your home
  • Qualifies for curbside pickup at local stores
  • Subscriptions can be set up for regular auto-delivery

What I Don’t Like About OptimPlus Dog Food

Reports Of Adverse Reactions in Dogs

Some pet owners have reported instances of digestive upset, irritation, or allergic reactions in dogs after transitioning to OptimPlus.

OptimPlus Dog Food Customer Review
Source: Reddit

Ingredients & Nutritional Profile

To offer this food at the most affordable price point, OptimPlus relies on plant-based fillers like corn, wheat, and soy rather than high-quality meats.

For instance, here is the full ingredient list for the OptimPlus Adult Sensitive Skin & Stomach Salmon & Oatmeal Formula Dry Dog Food:

Salmon; Oatmeal; Salmon Meal; Brown Rice; Pearled Barley; Menhaden Fish Meal; Beef Tallow; Brewers Dried Yeast; Flaxseed Meal; Natural Flavor; Salmon Oil; Dried Egg Product; Salt; Fructooligosaccharide; Dried Plain Beet Pulp; Potassium Chloride; Calcium Carbonate; Vitamin E Supplement; Choline Chloride; Zinc Methionine Complex; Citric Acid (a preservative); Mixed Tocopherols (a preservative); Dried Bacillus coagulans Fermentation Product; Zinc Sulfate; Niacin Supplement; Taurine; L-Ascorbyl-2-Polyphosphate; Iron Proteinate; Ferrous Sulfate; Copper Proteinate; Vitamin A Supplement; Copper Sulfate; Thiamine Mononitrate; d-Calcium Pantothenate; Manganese Proteinate; Pyridoxine Hydrochloride; Riboflavin Supplement; Sodium Selenite; Manganous Oxide; Vitamin D3 Supplement; Calcium Iodate; Biotin; Folic Acid; Vitamin B12 Supplement; Rosemary Extract.Contains a source of live (viable) naturally occurring microorganisms.

One Formulation for All Breeds/Dogs

OptimPlus takes a generalized one-size-fits-all approach to their formulas.

They do not offer customized recipes tailored to different breeds, activity levels or health conditions.

This limits the food’s suitability for dogs with unique nutritional needs.

Final Verdict: Should You Buy OptimPlus Dog Food?

While the affordability and accessibility of OptimPlus makes it appealing, I don’t feel it’s the best dog food choice overall due to the plant-based fillers and mixed dog owner reviews.

Instead, I would recommend exploring a human-grade, all-natural brand like Sundays for Dogs.

Their air-dried formulas are 90% meat and 10% added ‘superfoods’ without any synthetic additives.

At the same time, Sundays offers completely customized meal plans based on your dog’s unique needs across different ages, breeds, sensitivities, and health status.

Their nutrient-preserving prep locks in more flavors and vitamins than traditional kibble.

Additionally, Sundays is incredibly convenient to order online and have delivered regularly.

Subscriptions are available for automatic renewals.

The brand confidently states that meals typically work out 36% cheaper than other fresh food brands with less waste.

With human-grade ingredients tailored to your dog combined with stress-free serving and picky eater approved taste, Sundays provides a premium nutritious alternative to basic kibble like OptimPlus without the compromise.

While OptimPlus meets the minimums for an affordable price, if you want the very best for your dog’s health, Sundays’ customized fresh recipes are the way to go.

Related Questions

Is OptimPlus a good dog food?

Based on an analysis of the ingredients and general consensus from a wide range of customers, Optimplus does not appear to be the most optimal dog food brand for most dogs.